Is it actually Rafa to blame for Newcastle's poor start?!

My thoughts on Sunday's game are similar ones to those I have had over the past year watching Rafa Benitez’s team. We lack depth, we lack width and we lack movement off the ball whilst in possession. Pretty much the absolute basics of attacking play. Rafa may (rightfully) moan about missing out on specific transfer targets earlier in the window but this does not explain his needlessly negative strategy, line-ups and substitutions.

Before I go off on a possible rant I would like to make one thing perfectly clear, we are not a bad team. Don’t buy into the mainstream football media’s avalanche of misery they insist on piling onto our club whenever things don’t seem 100% right from the outside looking in. We were not outplayed by Huddersfield, much like we weren’t outplayed by Spurs last week when 11v11, and apart from their goal, the newly-promoted side hardly made a dent in terms of hurting our back line.

Out of both sides, it was us that had the biggest chance of the game when Ayoze Perez blasted over when completely unmarked from about 8 yards out. Substitutes Joselu & Murphy had opportunities to have a clear shot on goal but failed to make the most of them. Out of both goalkeepers, it was Huddersfield’s Jossl that had to pull off a fingertip save to keep out Ritchie’s effort in the first half. If that chance, or any of these chances, go in then it’s a different game and likely different result.

Now that the positives are out of the way, yes, they were positives honest, there is a big elephant in everyone’s room on Tyneside that nobody wants or is prepared to talk about. Some refuse to even acknowledge its very existence under any circumstances mainly due to bigger worries and concerns. However, at some stage, this has to be discussed and looked at. At some point, we need to talk about Rafa.

Amongst all the lack of transfers stuff & the Mike Ashley stuff and whatever other stuff fans want to talk or moan about, there has been one massively concerning issue that has been staring us all in the face over the past year. Rafa Benitez’s overly cautious and needlessly negative approach to our games. More specifically his tactics and use of the personnel he has at his disposal. Do we lack some quality? Yes. Do we have any quality? Yes. Is that quality being used in its capacity? No.

How we managed to win the Championship was quite remarkable to be perfectly honest. You can count on one hand the amount of games where we actually looked impressive and destroyed teams that were below our level. No one can say our Championship season wasn’t one hell of a long struggle. Some say, ‘well that’s the Championship’, maybe.

The more accurate thing to say however, is that we caused our own frustrations by not going about our business on the pitch anywhere near as positively and ambitiously as we should have. Wingers dropping deep and always coming short. Full backs chained to the halfway line and unable to get forward. Both centre midfielders dropping deep right in front of our centre-backs. It’s needless and it’s wrong.

Against Huddersfield these demons in Rafa’s philosophy raised their ugly head once again. 99% will put this down to ‘lack of quality’ or ‘they need more players’. I am telling you now, even with new and/or better players that won’t dispel the demons. The football club needs to change its philosophy when it comes to being cheap in the transfer market. But Rafa also needs to change his philosophy with the players he has. Neither are good enough at the moment.

Follow on Twitter @ToonBano


  1. I'm a big fan of Rafa. I think M.A. is incompetent at best. But i agree with everything said here. Additionally, I've been a bit surprised at how Rafa's been so persistently talking about our team not being good enough and how our signings aren't the ones we've wanted but rather who we've had to settle for - hardly confidence-boosting for the lads! I think current squad has about 50:50 chance of staying up. 2-3 good signings that actually improve the starting xi could see us go on to finish as high as 12th. So it's a big unknown. I do think Rafa sets up a bit too cautious at times, which is more understandable this year than last, but if M.A. blows it and Rafa leaves then who knows if we'll ever have the sort of opportunity to move forward that we're just scarcely clinging to at the moment. (Ps. How on earth has M.A. been successful in business? A schoolchild could understand the idea of speculating to accumulate, and that failure to invest is just a fool's economy where you end up losing even bigger. Even if the only thing you cared about in the world was your own wealth. Puzzling.)

    1. Absolutely cracking comment. Couldn't agree more with everything you said.

      ...and I only assume Ash has become a success with his cheap sports shop via paying for advisors and a whole load of luck.

    2. Could not agree more with the negative tactics employed by Rafa. To be honest the whining about transfers or there lack of is getting tiring. Drop Perez and Gayle to the bench, push Marino to No 10 behind Joselu and use Murphy. As for bringing on Mo when chasing a game why ?

    3. Yea cant disagree with your thinking. At least its something different.

      Mo Diame was embarrassing. Using him last year was one thing but when he had attacking option of Aarons, Murphy or Mitro it's utter nonsense.